jkpirtle,
You should only target your area of customers that will use your mat on a regular basis. Blanketing the area is not effective for the occasional customer since they would forget your ad by the time they needed to make the trip.
If you are offering a WDF service then blanketing the area would make more sense, but you need to know your market.
People are creatures of habit and will usually pass a new store to go to their store just out of habit. That is if they are happy with where they go. If your local competition is lacking a clean store and good service then your new store will probably not need hardly any advertising.
When it comes down to it, a well lighted clean store with good signage is your best strategy to bring in customers and from there it is word of mouth.
Just have some simple door hangers made up with your information (name, map, etc.) and hire a few people to go door to door in the rental properties to start the ball rolling. Offer a big discount for the first week to get those creatures of habit people in the door for the first time. You will be surprised on how well this can work at a minimal cost.
Duane.
www.LMARIES.com